35-37 High Street

Rye NY 10580

Property Profile


35-37 High Street | Rye | NY | 10580

  • Units: 5
  • Price/Unit: $ 270,000
  • Square Feet: 3,390 SF
  • Price/Square Foot: $ 398
  • Year Built: 1890
  • Cap Rate: 5.02%

The apartments located at 35-37 High Street, Rye NY is comprised of 5 free market units (3-two bedroom and 2-one bedroom) totaling 3,390 rentable SF in one-2.5 story building built in 1890. Situated on a 0.21 acre site there are 8 off-street parking spaces, a laundry facility, and a common garden. Three of the units have offices and three units have decks. Tenants pay for heat and hot water through individual gas boilers and hot water heaters.


The listing broker, Matthew Cawley had recently sold a 103-unit property in Rye, NY.  Having full knowledge of the most current rental rates in the small city allowed for effective discussion on the potential of the property with new buyers to the area.  The building was extensively marketed through internal email distribution lists, a direct mail marketing campaign, and placement on a national commercial listing platform.


With multiple bids on the property throughout the marketing period, the listing broker Matthew Cawley was able to help guide the owner on the selection of the offer with the right buyer.  This group timely closed on the property following the guidelines of the mutually agreed upon contract.  The listing broker was able to guide the owner through the contract period to complete specific inspections needed by the City of Rye so that closing was not delayed. The deal was closed on May 31st, 2022.


Share this property with your friends

Please type comma separated emails if you want to share these properties with multiple people.
Share this property

Request Information